Source
petapixel.com/2014/08/24/photo…
In the world of patents, some money, a lawyer and the carefully crafting a few hundred words can go a long way — for better or worse.
One such example is the case of Peter Wolf, owner of Photocrazy, a company that takes photos of sporting events such as triathlons, then offers prints to the participants by matching their race number to an internalized, searchable database.
And although this concept has been around for quite some time in various forms, EFF reveals that Wolf managed to get three patents on this generalized idea and is now attempting to squash other, smaller operations that use a similar method.
Specifically, 6,985,875; 7,047,214 and 7,870,035 are the patents Wolf has managed to secure with the help of some clever wording on behalf of his lawyer. The basis of the most vital component in primary claim — 6,985,875 — is the process of taking a photo of a sporting event, tagging and sorting the participants by their bib number and date of the event, then making available the photographs in an online search form using those variables.
Naturally, the patent filing explains it in far greater detail:
A process providing event photographs of a sporting event for inspection, selection and distribution via a computer network, comprising the steps of:
taking photographs of at least one participant of a sporting event along at least one point of a course or field thereof;
associating identifying data with each photograph taken, wherein the identifying data is selected from at least one of: a number corresponding to a number worn by a participant, a participant’s name, a code acquired from a component worn by a participant, and a date and time, including hour and minute the photograph was taken;
informing the sporting participants of the identifying data;
transferring the photographs to a computer network server;
cataloging each of the photographs in a web-site server according to the identifying data;
accessing the server at a location other than the sporting event and searching for a photograph of a particular sporting event participant utilizing the identifying data; and
displaying the photograph of the sporting event participant for inspection and ordering.
This patent is drawing a great deal of criticism though, considering there’s nothing exactly proprietary within the filings — it’s a conglomeration of already-existing general concepts. With the patents in hand though, Wolf is able to effectively control this generalized idea and file lawsuits against other, smaller operations.
The first is a rather small company called Capstone, which has been using a similar workflow for their images for quite some time. Wolf is looking to sue them for doing so. Fortunately, two previous cases — Alice v. CLS ruling and Limelight v. Akamai ruling — make it seem like these patents could be rendered invalid for a number of reasons.
Even if the patents are determined invalid though, Capstone and any future company using a similar workflow aren’t quite off the hook.
Legal fees alone could collapse a small company such as Capstone, which is made up of almost completely part-time workers. Capstone is attempting to crowdfund support for the lawsuit, but only $5,000 has come through, which is just a drop in the bucket of the impending legal fees, regardless of whether the patent is ruled valid or not.
One way or another, cases like this show just how counterintuitive patents can be, when their original purpose was to create, not stifle, innovation.
ShopDreamUp AI ArtDreamUp
Deviation Actions
Admins wanted!
Hi there everyone! :wave:
Thanks for hanging in there... Unfortunately we are still in need of some new admins due to the amount of submissions to the group. The admins that are left can't do the job by themselves.
We are looking for admins that are:
:bulletpurple: Competent to that extent that you can give good feedback
:bulletpurple: Motivated to help other deviants improve their work
:bulletpurple: Dedicated to spending a little bit of your spare time contributing to this group
:bulletpurple: Polite to members and other admins
I hope some of our members now will consider joining our admin team :airborne: We really need all the help we
PHOTOGRAPHY CONTEST IV
Time for another contest!
All the information is here!
:thumb610372360:
Good news, everyone!
You can now submit 2 photos per week! :party: It takes 4 votes for your photos to be accepted or declined.
Keep up the good work!
WE ARE STILL ALIVE. BARELY. ADMINS WANTED!
Hello fellow deviants!
We're in some deep trouble. :(
As you may have noticed, this group's slowly dying of stagnancy and we need some fresh breeze!
The admin team is on its knees because of too many submissions and to be honest, there's only 2-3 people voting, so they can't do everything by themselves.
What we need right now are competent people who have the time and motivation to help out other photographers and would like to join our team.
If you feel like you could do this and would like help us create a new dynamic team of admins, send us a note and introduce yourself a little. It can be a one simple sentence introduction, if you don
Featured in Groups
© 2014 - 2024 iLovePhotographyClub
Comments2
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Log In
This patent is ridicules. It would be like Google patenting web search. I agree with Siochanna, patent trolling must end.. I personally believe patents are holding back technology innovation.